Agent's view · Dubai · My criteria
What I refuse to sell my clients
An agent is also judged by the sales he does not make. I am Ahmed Benjas, a Moroccan real estate agent in Dubai, and these are my red lines: the deals I turn down, even when the client is ready to sign.
Dubai towers by the waterThe short answer
I refuse to sell a property when the money does not go through the official channel, when the ad is not authorised, when what is being sold is a promise rather than a contract, or when the payment plan does not fit the client's real life. These are not tastes. They are risks I will not put on someone who trusts me.
My seven red lines, in one list:
- An off-plan payment that does not go to the project's escrow account: Dubai law requires it, and I make no exception
- An ad without a permit or QR code that can be checked with the Dubai Land Department
- A "guaranteed return" presented as a certainty, with no contract saying who guarantees what
- A payment plan the client cannot carry, above all at handover
- A Golden Visa promised on a purchase that does not reach the official threshold
- A quick resale sold as a gain already made, when entry costs already eat the margin
- A signature under pressure, before the client has read and understood the contract
Why an agent has to be able to say no
In Dubai, the agent is paid when the sale happens. That is a real conflict of interest, and I would rather say it plainly than pretend it does not exist. The only way I know to manage it is to have rules written down in advance, which I apply before I look at the commission.
These rules come from more than twenty years in finance, where you learn quickly that a client who was badly served does not come back, and from my work as a RERA-licensed broker (BRN 83239). They complete the method I describe in how to check a Dubai developer and project. The checks tell you whether a project is compliant; my red lines tell you whether that project suits the person sitting in front of me.
Red line 1: money outside the escrow account
This is the most important one, and it is not negotiable. Dubai Law No. 8 of 2007 provides that a developer must be registered and licensed (article 4), must apply to open an escrow account before selling off-plan (article 6), and that off-plan buyers' payments are deposited into that account (article 7). The same law states that the developer's creditors cannot seize the amounts held in it (article 9).
When someone suggests that I "settle part of it directly", in cash, to a personal account or to the account of an intermediary company, I say no. Whatever the discount on offer, a payment outside escrow leaves the protection the law provides.
What I offer instead: every instalment goes to the escrow account named in the contract and on the payment request, and the transfer receipt is kept. Cevitas explains how escrow works in detail in its page on how escrow protects your off-plan money, and I cover the order of transfers in paying for a Dubai property from abroad.
Red line 2: the ad you cannot verify
The same law forbids a developer to advertise or take part in an exhibition to sell off-plan without written approval from the Dubai Land Department (article 5). Since 24 April 2023, according to the Dubai Media Office, every property ad permit carries a QR code (the Madmoun service) that companies must display. Scanning it confirms that the ad is authorised and shows the details of the property and the advertiser.
I do not present a client with a property whose ad has no permit, and I am wary of a price well below the market that circulates on a messaging app with no reference at all. I also check that the person on the other side is a broker listed in the DLD's official register. I am, and anyone selling you a property in Dubai should be too.
Red line 3: the "guaranteed" return
Some offers headline a rental return guaranteed for a few years. I am not saying these arrangements are illegal. I am saying I refuse to present them as a certainty. A guarantee is worth what the contract that writes it is worth, and what the party that gives it is worth.
When a guarantee is offered, I ask for three answers in writing: who exactly pays it (the developer, a management company, another entity), on what base it is calculated (purchase price, price before fees), and what happens when the period ends. If those answers are not in the contract, I leave the guarantee out of the calculation. My yield calculations always use market rents, with service charges and vacancy, as ranges.
Red line 4: the payment plan that cannot hold
Off-plan, the danger almost never comes from the first instalment. It comes from the handover payment, when a large share of the price falls due at once. I refuse to sell a payment plan when the client cannot pay the handover amount with money they already have, or when the financing is only an assumption. A mortgage at handover is never a given: the bank decides at the time, on its own criteria. How to read a schedule is covered in my guide to off-plan payment plans.
My grid: what I refuse, and what I offer instead
This is the grid I apply. It does not rule a project out for ever: it says what has to change before I can recommend it.
| Situation | Why I say no | What I offer instead |
|---|---|---|
| Payment in cash, to a personal account or outside escrow | Outside Law No. 8 of 2007: the escrow protection does not apply | Transfers only to the project's escrow account, receipts kept |
| Ad without a permit or QR code | No way to check that the DLD authorised the ad | Only properties whose ad can be verified |
| "Guaranteed" return with no precise contract | A promise is not income; the guarantee depends on who gives it | A calculation on market rents, charges and vacancy, as ranges |
| Handover financed by a hypothetical mortgage | The bank decides at handover; a refusal puts the client in default | A plan whose handover is covered by identified funds |
| Golden Visa promised below the threshold | The official threshold is not reached: the promise is false | A budget at the threshold, or a project with no visa promise |
| Quick resale presented as a gain already made | Entry costs (4% to the DLD plus related fees) still have to be recovered | A project that also works as a hold if the resale takes longer |
| Signature demanded the same day | Nobody should sign a contract they have not read | Time to read the contract, clause by clause, before any payment |
Example: the payment plan I had scaled down
A fictitious case, to show the reasoning. Samira is Moroccan and lives in London. She has spotted an off-plan flat at AED 1.2 million on a 20 / 40 / 40 plan: 20% at reservation, 40% during construction, 40% at handover. Today she has the equivalent of about AED 400,000, and she is counting on a mortgage for the handover.
- At reservation: 20% of the price, or AED 240,000, plus the 4% DLD fee, or AED 48,000, plus administrative fees. About AED 290,000 leaves her account on day one.
- During construction: AED 480,000 to pay. With the roughly AED 110,000 she has left, she must save the rest over two to three years, which is already tight.
- At handover: another AED 480,000, resting entirely on a mortgage that nobody can promise her today.
- My answer: I do not sell her this property at this price. I suggest a lower budget, or a plan whose handover is covered by what she will really have saved, while keeping a reserve for the unexpected (exchange rate, delays, service charges).
I make no promise about where prices will go. If the resale takes longer than hoped, Samira must be able to keep the property without being put in difficulty. That test, more than the advertised yield, is what decides whether I recommend a purchase.
Red line 5: the Golden Visa below the threshold
The official u.ae portal sets the property value that opens the Golden Visa for an investor at AED 2 million. I refuse to let a purchase be presented as "Golden Visa eligible" when it does not reach that threshold, or when eligibility depends on conditions the client does not meet. The details, including the Moroccan documents, are in the UAE Golden Visa for Moroccans.
Red line 6: the quick resale sold as a sure thing
Reselling before handover is possible, depending on the contract and the developer's conditions. But between the 4% paid to the Dubai Land Department, administrative fees, any transfer fee and the commission on resale, the price has to rise for real just for you to get your money back. I refuse to sell a quick resale as a certain gain. If a project only works in the scenario where prices rise fast, I advise against it.
Red line 7: the signature under pressure
Launches move fast in Dubai, and that is normal. But if a client is being pushed so hard that they cannot read their contract, I step back. A good project can wait a few days for checks. I read the sale and purchase agreement with each client, in English, French or Darija, before the first payment.
The other traps, from the buyer's side, are in the mistakes to avoid when buying in Dubai from abroad.
What these refusals do not mean
Turning a deal down does not mean a developer is dishonest, or that a project is bad for everyone. Often the same property would suit another client, with another budget or another time horizon. My red lines are about the fit between a product and a person, not about passing judgement.
Nor do they guarantee that a purchase will be profitable. Property remains a risky investment, exposed to prices, rents, currency and delays. My red lines remove the risks that can be avoided; they do not remove market risk.
My role, and its limits
I am a RERA-licensed broker in Dubai (BRN 83239), co-founder and CEO of Cevitas Real Estate (ORN 49294). I am not a lawyer or a tax adviser: for a complex structure, independent legal advice completes my reading. Rules change, so always check the version in force with the relevant authority.
You have an offer in hand and a doubt? Send it to me and I will tell you plainly whether it passes my grid, and why.
Your roadmap
Your project, in 60 seconds.
Five questions, and I reply personally with a first reading of your project: where, how, and in what order.
- A personal reply from Ahmed
- A free 30-minute call
- No commitment
Step 1 of 5
Where do you live today?
Official sources
- Government of Dubai · Law No. 8 of 2007 concerning escrow accounts for real estate development
- Dubai Media Office · DLD makes the QR code (Madmoun service) mandatory on property ads, April 2023
- Official UAE Government portal (u.ae) · Golden Visa
- Dubai Land Department · Register of licensed real estate brokers
- Dubai Land Department · rules and procedures
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Can a real estate agent in Dubai refuse to sell a property to a client?
Yes. Nothing obliges an agent to close a sale he considers unsuitable. I decline deals that leave the official channel (payment outside escrow, an ad without a permit) or that do not match the client's financial capacity.
How do I check that a property ad in Dubai is authorised?
Since 24 April 2023, every ad permit carries a QR code (the Dubai Land Department's Madmoun service) that the advertiser must display. Scanning it confirms that the ad is authorised and shows the details of the property and the advertiser.
Is a guaranteed rental return in Dubai reliable?
It is worth what the contract that writes it is worth, and what the party paying it is worth. Ask in writing who guarantees it, on what base and for how long. I never include it in a calculation without those answers.
Can I pay part of an off-plan property in cash or directly to the developer?
I refuse to do it. Dubai Law No. 8 of 2007 provides that off-plan buyers' payments are deposited into the project's escrow account. Paying anywhere else takes you outside that protection.
Should I avoid payment plans with a large handover payment?
Not necessarily, but you need to know what money will pay it. If the handover depends on a mortgage nobody can guarantee today, the risk of default is real. I prefer a plan whose final payment is covered by identified funds.
Does a purchase of AED 2 million automatically give a Golden Visa?
The u.ae portal sets AED 2 million as the property value for an investor's Golden Visa, but the application has its own conditions and documents. I never present a purchase as eligible until the client's file has been checked against the official conditions in force.
Read next
Contact
Let's talk about your project.
One message is enough. I reply personally, in English, French, Arabic or Darija.
